Image
Ciudad Juarez

credit: public domain image on Wikipedia

Rethinking estrangement, interventions, and intimate femicide

Study
North America

Executive Summary

In this insightful piece, Dr.'s Desmond Ellis and Walter S. DeKeseredy expand upon Wilson and Daly's theory of male proprietariness. Specifically, the authors explore various intervention mechanisms alongside the male proprietariness thesis in an attempt to identify prevention measures for violence against women and femicide. This article is only accessible with journal subscription.

Author(s)

Desmond Ellis
Walter S. DeKeseredy

Defining Intimate Femicide

"[...] the killing of females by male partners with whom they have, had had, or want to have, a sexual and/or emotional relationship."

(Ellis & DeKeseredy, 1997, pg. 592)

Defining Estrangement

"[...] a process in which one or both partners become alienated from each other. Separation (emotional/affective and physical) is usually associated with estrangement and is often an indicator of it."

(Ellis & DeKeseredy, 1997, pg.592)

Defining Male Proprietariness

"Following Wilson and Daly (1992b), male proprietariness is defined as "the tendency [of men] to think of women as sexual and reproductive 'property' they can own and exchange" (p.85). More generally, proprietariness refers to "not just the emotional force of [the male's] own feelings of entitlement but to a more pervasive attitude [of ownership and control] toward social relationships [with intimate female partners]" (p. 85)."

(Ellis & Dekeseredy, 1997, pg. 592)

Defining Voice, Exit and Loyalty

"Hirschman (1970) defines voice as "an expression of protest or dissatisfaction," exit as "leaving or buying a competitor's products or services," and loyalty as "attachment or relatively inelastic demand for services/products" (p. 2). In applying the mechanisms of exit, voice, and loyalty to intimate relationships, three modifications are necessary. First, Hirschman applies these mechanisms to "the concept of a random and more or less easily repairable lapse." In this article, they are applied to systematic recurring harms inflicted by males on their intimate female partners. Second, Hirschman conceives of exit, voice, and loyalty as "recuperative mechanisms." However, we view them as mechanisms for disintegrating or severing as well as reintegrating intimate relationships. Third, for Hirschman, voice ends with exit (1970, p. 43). In the application of these mechanisms to intimate relationships, however, escalated violence following exit is frequently encountered.

(Ellis & DeKeseredy, 1997, pg. 593)

Increasing the social and legal costs of battering are effective in getting chronic and sporadic batterers to stop battering. Extremely dependent males who may not batter, but may kill their partners and themselves, require either intensive treatments very early on in the relationship or an early exit from it.

 

 


 

Interested in joining
our team? Questions
or comments?

Connect with us:  
twitter @femicidewatch

Imprint link icon & 
Privacy Policy link icon

Email us: editors (at)
femicide-watch.org

UNSA Global Network
UNSA Vienna

powered by
enlightenment GmbH

UNSA Vienna

UNSA GN

enlightenment logo